
Sitaare Zameen Par, Review: Lots of sympathy, very little empathy
Aamir Khan has earned for himself the sobriquet of a crusader, or an actor with a conscience. Several of his films have dealt with social issues, as in Taare Zameen Par (autism) and PK (an alien who helps earthlings to battle social evils), or cricket+revolt against British imperialism of yore (Lagaan). He also hosted a TV show, wherein he tried to get justice for sufferers of societal victimisation and injustice. So, making a film about differently abled and challenged persons is a logical step forward in his mission, if I may classify his forays above, as such. In Sitaare Zameen Par, which means exactly the same as Taare Zameen Par (Taare and Sitaare are interchangeable in Hindustani, both meaning Stars on Earth), the spiritual sequel to Taare Zameen Par, he chooses to focus on persons afflicted with differing conditions, Down’s syndrome and Autism being two of them. He has to train a bunch of affected individuals as basketball players, and don the role of their basketball coach. We have seen other actors, including ShahRukh Khan, play coaches to sport teams, and lead them, from being underdogs to champions. So the platform is not innovative. And if we look at the net result of this effort, Sitaare Zameen Par generates a lot of sympathy, but very little empathy.
In New Delhi, an arrogant, opinionated and ill-tempered assistant basketball coach, Gulshan Arora, gives unwanted and unwelcome advice to his senior coach during a match, repeatedly. The coach castigates him and asks him to shut-up. Gulshan punches him in the face. Later, he gets drunk and drives his car himself, breaking another car’s rear-view mirror, and even causing damage to a police car, that sets out to stop him. Somehow, the coach is persuaded not to file a case against Gulshan, although Gulshan cannot escape suspension. But in the matter of the dual car banging, he is put on trial. Although he is condescending and egotistic, the judge, a woman, is considerate, because he is a coach, and has no previous criminal record. She sentences him to three months of community service, which entails coaching a basketball team, comprising mentally challenged players. Gulshan finds the sentence ridiculous and refuses to coach “mad people”, but is prevailed upon by his family and well-wishers to accept the sentence, for otherwise, it would mean heavy fines, or jail, or both. The judge fines him Rs. 10,000, for disrespecting the dignity of the court, and, he accepts the service sentence, reluctantly.
When he arrives at the community service centre where the coaching is to take place, he is met by Kartar Singh, the manager of the place. Kartar is a charming man and uses earthy metaphors to explain complicated things, like the under-developed brains of his wards. When Gulshan sees the players for the first time, he is shocked by their appearances, angry at their behaviour, which is due to their “not normal” manifestations and angry at their brat like antics. But, over time, with the guidance of Kartar Singh, he manages to gradually overcome his prejudices. He also learns that one of the members of his team, the tallest, is a nephew of the judge who sentenced him, and perhaps this was one factor in awarding him the sentence. Co-incidentally, Gulshan is short in height, touching 5’ 6”, about the same as the average height of the players. Meanwhile, his marriage is on the rocks, and he lives separately, from his wife Suneeta, staying with his mother. The main reason for the incompatibility is the self-centred nature of Gulshan, and his unwillingness to father a child. Within a matter of weeks, Gulshan manages to bring out the best in the basketball team. Kartar wants them to participate in tournament